22
votes
Reopening a duplicate so you can add an answer, then reclosing it?
Unilaterally reopening a question to answer it and then unilaterally closing it again is not an appropriate use of one's unilateral closing and reopening privileges.
The privilege is not meant to give ...
- 18.3k
21
votes
Can anything be done about prolific blind question bashing?
I've noticed that you have a strong tendency to go on the offensive when anyone makes a comment that you disagree with. You comment-flood them with multiple responses explaining why they're wrong, and ...
- 710k
21
votes
Accepted
Reopening a duplicate so you can add an answer, then reclosing it?
The question's timeline shows that it was re-opened on 2023-11-04 at 23:14:10Z, answered at 23:15:25Z, and re-closed with the same duplicate target at 23:18:17Z by the same user -- a span of just over ...
NullMod
- 70.2k
18
votes
Accepted
Why was this 'not an answer' flag on a rant about US declined?
There is an answer buried in that wall of text:
So back to question, why would a Jedi serve a corrupt democracy? well why are our leaders doing the same thing in real life? because generations of ...
NullMod
- 70.2k
17
votes
Accepted
User changed their question into a completely different question. Is this allowed?
It's entirely inappropriate for OP to completely rewrite their question into an entirely different question, especially when the existing question had upvotes.
It invalidates the comment-chain
It ...
- 710k
16
votes
Why does the community continue re-opening this particular question?
I can't speak for those who voted to reopen, but my personal opinion is that your argument is fundamentally flawed. What you seem to be saying is that there's simply no objective way to determine that ...
- 710k
16
votes
Why was this 'not an answer' flag on a rant about US declined?
Although I can't comment on the particular moderator's reasons for declining the NAA flags, I agree with the decision; despite all the noise, there is an answer in there:
why would a Jedi serve a ...
- 164k
16
votes
Accepted
Why did a moderator delete this question about a paradox?
Update #2
The question has now been mod-hammered open by moderator Thaddeus Howze.
Update #1
The question, having initially been deleted by moderator Thaddeus Howze, has now been undeleted by ...
- 710k
16
votes
Is this an unpopular type of question?
“Any” questions generally receive a few downvotes and there certainly is a group of users that don’t like them, myself included. The problem is whilst they were ruled to be on topic they are ...
- 144k
16
votes
Accepted
What to do when you know the answer to a question closed for needing more details
You've pretty much hit the nail on the head.
Commenting that you think you know the answer is fine.
Commenting with the answer is even better as you might get a response from OP to confirm it (in ...
- 710k
15
votes
Accepted
Who founded Science Fiction and Fantasy?
Users did in essence. Sites on Stack Exchange are created by going through Area 51 (or at least were). If enough users like the proposal and participate on the site that it gets enough content and ...
- 144k
14
votes
Why can't I use the word "mudblood"?
Even though it is a made up word, it does not follow the Be Nice policy. This policy also applies to public figures.
In specific I think this hits the nail on the head:
Don't be a jerk. These are ...
- 61.3k
14
votes
Do we still need to keep this thread locked?
The reason rejected spam edits used to be a problem is because even when rejected they were still publicly visible and spammers would use that as proof to their clients they had successfully spammed ...
- 101
13
votes
Accepted
What's the problem with this question?
Let's start with the good. The question itself is perfectly well written in high quality English, is correctly tagged and has a sensible title which matches the body question, all of which are why I ...
- 710k
13
votes
Is "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer" on-topic?
Yes. in this instance the song (and its source-poem) are thoroughly on-topic given that they're a fantasy that merely happens to have a christmassy setting.
Robert L. May created Rudolph in 1939, ...
- 710k
13
votes
Why it's so hard to please the admins here on this site?
The question wasn't put on hold by any admins (they're called moderators on Stack Exchange) — it was voted so by regular users.
How
The Stack Exchange Theory of Moderation is that the users moderate....
- 39.1k
13
votes
Duplicates: “Yesterday Was Monday” versus “A Matter of Minutes”
You're not wrong. This question (1) is asking about the short story. The other two questions (2, 3) are asking about the TV episode.
2 and 3 are clearly duplicates of each other. 1 isn't, so I've un-...
- 710k
12
votes
Accepted
Why was this flag disputed?
Arguably this lump of text
"if like I said elves have dominant traits that would have a higher
chance to pass through each generation instead of the human ones then
technically Aragon would ...
- 710k
12
votes
Why was the question "Why was Jake and the Never Land Pirates cancelled?" migrated to Movies?
I'm not a mod so I can't speak for the exact reasons this happened but looking at it, it does makes sense.
Consensus appears to be do not cross post 99% of the time with the only times being ...
- 144k
12
votes
Why was the question "Why was Jake and the Never Land Pirates cancelled?" migrated to Movies?
it is considered acceptable to re-ask that question on to a new Stack Exchange site if you feel that the answers you received from the earlier time do not meet your requirements or expectations.
...
Rand al'ThorMod
- 135k
12
votes
Can anything be done about prolific blind question bashing?
I've downvoted some of your questions but not the ones you mention here. I rarely comment when I downvote because the purpose of downvotes is not primarily to give the OP feedback, it's to give ...
- 9,730
11
votes
Accepted
Would this Dragons question be on-topic?
It depends.
As written, it's not entirely clear what your specific question is.
If you're wanting to know whether the growth cycles of this author's fictional dragons were based directly on a real ...
- 710k
11
votes
Accepted
What is the standard for answering "What was the plagiarised story published by Asimov’s?"?
As long as you can reasonably back up your assertion it's not libel, it's fair comment and there are a number of ways you could answer this question in a high quality fashion;
Locate an authoritative ...
- 710k
10
votes
Accepted
Should we prefer questions with accepted answers when closing identification requests as duplicate?
No
Comments are fine to be used for closing as a duplicate, all that matters is that we have confirmation. This is because not all users know that you can accept an answer, especially new users (and ...
- 144k
10
votes
Accepted
Help me understand why my Star Trek question is on hold as 'unclear'?
I don't think your question falls under the category of Unclear What You're Asking. I don't think I've ever seen an episode of Star Trek, but I was able to understand the question. In fact, both other ...
- 45k
10
votes
Accepted
Is this truly a story-id question?
The story-id tag is for the generic identification of any science fiction or fantasy property. It doesn't strictly have to be a (written) story. It could also be a game, song, film, book, movie or ...
- 710k
10
votes
Accepted
Reopen request for the "Adventure book, possibly published around 25 years ago" question
In this case, I think it probably should be reopened, and I've voted accordingly.
For my money, it meets the smell-test of being just about answerable, due to the presence of a few different tropes (...
- 710k
10
votes
What is the standard for answering "What was the plagiarised story published by Asimov’s?"?
I think the libel concern isn't really very large. An answer (that isn't rapidly downvoted and probably deleted) will have to meet all the criteria of the question and the comments (published January ...
- 139k
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible