14 votes
Accepted

Are we now allowing list questions that are long or that change over time?

List questions were barred for a specific reason, and it's not the word "list" in them, but specific incompatibilities with SE Q&A format (specifically, that the question will result in endless, ...
12 votes

Why are so many questions unnecessarily answered with lists? And how to prevent it?

Answers are not just for the original questioner If you are asking a question, you are certainly free to say that you prefer brief, concise answers. You can reward brief, concise answers with up ...
  • 20.5k
10 votes

Why are so many questions unnecessarily answered with lists? And how to prevent it?

It is not a list, it is research! By showing why you came to a conclusion, through the exploration of different avenues, is the way great answers are built. The "list" reduces comments saying "Hey ...
  • 59k
9 votes

Why are so many questions unnecessarily answered with lists? And how to prevent it?

Why list answers are provided People like lists This is an easy thing to understand, as far as formatting is concerned, lists provide an easy way to: Break up your sentence and paragraph structures ...
  • 44.5k
7 votes

Is Asking For Work on a Very Niche (Not Easily Researched) Specific Topic Not Allowed?

The central premise of stackexchange is not, to replace google, but to provide pairings of high quality questions to single correct answers. Any "recommendation" is already going to be primarily ...
  • 81.8k
5 votes

Is Asking For Work on a Very Niche (Not Easily Researched) Specific Topic Not Allowed?

Your question wasn't facing closure because it was a list question, but because requests for works on a specific theme/style/subject are strictly off-topic on SFF:SE (and have been since its inception)...
  • 637k
4 votes

Would be asking for a list of plot holes of some work (with strong restrictions) be acceptable?

We generally say a small finite list question is acceptable. Can everyone agree on the definition of a plot hole? A plot hole, or plothole is a gap or inconsistency in a storyline that creates a ...
3 votes

Would be asking for a list of plot holes of some work (with strong restrictions) be acceptable?

No, the question you're planning to pose is not acceptable. Without border or boundaries, it's basically an open-ended list. There's no "right" answer. Dumping it as a community wiki doesn't make it ...
  • 637k
3 votes
Accepted

Is Asking For Work on a Very Niche (Not Easily Researched) Specific Topic Not Allowed?

There are several problems with such a question. Note that that when I say "problems," that does not imply that the question is "bad." Indeed, in my opinion it is a very interesting question. However,...
  • 114k
1 vote

Why are so many questions unnecessarily answered with lists? And how to prevent it?

If you can't say something new, say something better (and more is always better). Consider this, there is a question you know the answer to, but none of the 3 existing answers say what you think the ...
  • 32.3k

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible