I had been working on the question on and off for the past eight months.
I went to great lengths to answer this, even checking leads that had been largely dismissed. Apart from the obvious search attempts, here are some specific things I tried.
Consulting with R.L. Stine
The OP mentioned,
I don't think it was R.L. Stine, but I cannot remember the author.
We have the most active blog on the entire SE network, at least as confirmed by a CM:
JNat: You have the most active blog.
We’ve had a number of consistently high-quality contributions. Naturally, most are from JackBNimble and other high-reputation users, but we’ve had some contributions from newer users such as Rincewind. I was even ...
What We Can Expect From 2019
Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse in 100 words or less – Spoiler Free
Ralph Breaks the Internet Review in 100 Words or Less – Spoiler-Free
Highlights from 2018 – 3rd Quarter
Jack’s Bad Movies: The Punisher (1989)
Jack’s Bad Movies: Nick Fury: Agent of SHIELD (1998)
Jack’s Bad Movies: ...
Since the blogs are now "unofficial" blogs, I think we can relax a bit on what we limit ourselves to. So, my opinion is, if it's an article you think would be of interest to this community, it's fair game for the blog.
In the case of a video game review, I think you'd have to be aware of who your target audience is. We're here because we like to watch/read/...
I would love to see more of the great content which is produced on the SFF blog, and I have several brewing ideas and half-written posts for it myself. Please let's not allow this great resource, which allows our users to wonderfully express their creativity in a different way from writing great questions and answers, and which sets us apart from all ...
The description had me completely fooled. I thought it was kiddie-lit; it never occurred to me that it was a story published in a regular science fiction magazine. That saved me from ransacking my collection for it, which would not have done any good. I reposted the question in the Children's section of the BookSleuth Forum at Abebooks.com, but got no ...
I tried when I first joined the site, but to no avail.
In order to atone for my dismal failure I've contented myself with helping Kyle Hale by editing in some quotes from the story itself (and a nice picture) and offering a chunky bounty.
I really liked CreationEdge's answer to the very unpopular question:
Why does Captain America's costume change in all the movies?
The answer was clearly well-researched and answered both in-universe and out-of-universe
Creation even received a nice and well-deserved Reversal badge for his efforts too.
All of Aegon'...
The Autobiography of Jean-Luc Picard
Recent Star Wars Novels, Reviewed
Andy Weir's Artemis: A Novel
Justice League Does Fans, and DC, Justice
Live Chat: Star Wars Holiday Special
Highlights from 2017 – 3rd Quarter
Marvel’s Inhumans: Way better than you think.
Jack's Bad Movies: Colossal (2016)
Not my story, but some interesting statistics related to this post.
Here's a graph of the votes on both question and answer over time:
With nearly 6000 rep, Kyle Hale is easily the person on this site with the most rep earned from a single post. His answer has also earned more points in bounties than any other answer on the entire Stack Exchange network.
I'm biased, because it's my question, but I really like DCOPTimDowd's answer to my question of What went down at the July 1974 Comic Art Con?. He put quite a bit of effort into explaining the circumstances and the people involved. It's a bit of an odd duck as a question on the site, being about the fandom, but people seem to have received it well.
Assassin’s Creed – A (mostly) spoiler-free review
Jack’s Bad Movies – Alien Uprising (2012)
Doctor Strange – A (mostly) spoiler-free review
Timeless – Pilot
Highlights from 2016 – 3rd Quarter
A review of the Stonewylde series
Salt Lake Comic Con 2016 Recap
Coverage of Salt Lake Comic Con 2016
Help Keep The SFF Blog Running
Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace (1999) – Re-watch
The Mandalorian (Pilot)
Yesterday (2019) – A Review
Highlights from 2019 – 3rd Quarter
FanX Salt Lake Comic Convention (Fall 2019)
Highlights from 2019 – 2nd Quarter
Men in Black: International a Spoiler ...
I think Hannover Fist deserves a special mention for the inventiveness and charm of his question about management policy:
Could I fake death to stop being Force-choked?
And I rather liked Praxis' question which was both topical and amusing:
Which 2015 technologies were correctly predicted by Back to the Future II?
Not to blow my own ...
This answer MUST get a mention:
Story where the number 3 is the monster?
This question used to be the highest-voted question on the Unanswered tab, by a factor of about 3, until Kyle Hale solved it with his first (and so far only) post on SFF. He's earned more rep from a single post than anyone else on SFF, by far, and this answer has earned more ...
Has JKR addressed the issue of 'Love Potions' equating to date-rape drugs?
Given the apparent inconsistencies in the books, I had often wondered what Rowling’s opinion was.
In Tolkien's opinion, does Tom Bombadil (and the concept of pacifism) actually hold any power?
This is that rare question that (a) requires a good deal of ...
I think we should mention the Big Edit Event held on March 11 and 12.
After Stack Exchange announced mass HTTPS, it turned out that a metric tonne of images would die if we did not take action.
Mithrandir then proposed a solution:
Is it time to organize a major editing event?
Which was agreed upon and later implemented:
The Big Edit Event (is finished)
Jessica Jones season one review
A Guide To The DC Cinematic Multiverse
Story where the number 3 is the monster: Finally Answered!
Highlights from 2015 – 3rd Quarter
Salt Lake Comic Con 2015 Summary
Minority Report – Pilot
Live Chat: The Day the Earth Stood Still (1951)
Fantastic Four: A (mildly spoilery) ...
The user(s) Victim of Circumstance deserve(s) a mention for their many great answers on questions about Tolkien's legendarium, including but not limited to:
When Frodo was guided by Gollum to the Black Gate, how did he intend to enter Mordor?
Poisoned weapons in Middle-earth
What would be the translation of “non-elf” in Elvish?
What did Gandalf mean when he ...
Technologies We Should Have In 2015
Jack’s Bad Movies – AE: Apocalypse Earth
Doom Star Series (books)
Detective Comics #27 – Introduction of the Batman
Science Fiction Technologies that People are Hoping for in Their Lifetime
Favorite Questions and Answers of All Time
The Flash – Pilot Episode
Highlights from 2014 – ...
Two of my personal favourites:
I really liked the answers and discussion on SQB’s question How did Dumbledore, or anyone, know Lily had sacrificed herself for Harry?
It’s a well-posed question that invites discussion, which is nice because I think a lot of the recent Harry Potter questions have focused more on trivia than discussion. There are several ...
The reason I suggested it was because I re-read this answer by Jeff to Are all Stormtroopers as poor soldiers as the ones in the movies?, and thought (again) that this is my single favorite answer on the entire website.
It's one of those answers that just shattered my preconceived notions about one of my favorite titles in a way that makes me enjoy the ...
Here are my nominations, in no particular order:
N_Soong's question Is there anyone Strickland doesn't think is a slacker? made me laugh
I enjoyed Richard's question Who (or what) is Unbreakable?, which deconstructs something that might be taken for granted otherwise
Dr R Dizzle's question Does the general public know who superheroes really ...
In no particular order:
randal'thor's question When did pure-historical Doctor Who go out of fashion? — I like questions that track trends in long-running science fiction works!
N_Soong's question Are any regular bridge crew on TNG actually members of the next generation? — One of those questions that few would think about ...