Questions tagged [specific-question]
For use when inquiring about a particular question e.g. inquiring about a specific question's suitability for this site.
181
questions
8
votes
1answer
127 views
Would this Dragons question be on-topic?
I was going to post the following question about Dragons in Temeraire, but looking for appropriate tags started to think it might be off topic as science based. Could I get a feeling in the room?
In ...
6
votes
1answer
197 views
How can I pose this question, without it being flagged as a duplicate?
I want to ask the following question:
What is the dependence between volumes of The History of Middle-earth?
This is a very similar to a question already asked, What to read in History of Middle-earth?...
9
votes
3answers
163 views
Is The Clan of the Cave Bear (and related works) on topic?
I just stumbled upon this well-asked and received question about the series of novels of which Clan of the Cave Bear is the first book. While certainly fictional, and predicated upon imaginative ...
9
votes
1answer
146 views
Should the question "What to read in History of Middle-earth?" have been closed?
The question in question: What to read in History of Middle-earth?
It's had a little bit of history to it, originally closed as a dupe to: In what order should Tolkien's writings on Middle-earth ...
11
votes
1answer
153 views
Duplicates: “Yesterday Was Monday” versus “A Matter of Minutes”
We seem to have a bit of a tangled situation with [story-identification] questions involving the Theodore Sturgeon short story “Yesterday was Monday” and the 1986 Twilight Zone episode “A Matter of ...
13
votes
2answers
209 views
Are stories set in settings that do not exist, yet which otherwise have no magical or speculative elements, on topic?
I thought this had been discussed before, but I can't seem to find a meta question about it.
There was a story-identification question today, to which the answer was Lloyd's Alexander's Westmark ...
9
votes
0answers
178 views
Why has the question "Where did Horace Walpole get the adjective "Gothic" to describe The Castle of Otranto?" been closed as off topic?
This question: Where did Horace Walpole get the adjective "Gothic" to describe The Castle of Otranto? which I asked last night has been closed (although I cannot see by whom). Apart from a ...
1
vote
1answer
55 views
Should this question about list of references go on the main sci-fi and fantasy site?
I looked around the other SE sites and found maybe one other SE site that this question could fall under (Literature), but the help section from both of these sites don't say whether or not its on or ...
-2
votes
1answer
149 views
Why was this question about Captain America closed?
My question about fanfic on Captain America was closed, but no explanation was given. It was closed as "off topic" but there are other questions about Captain America, Marvel Cinematic Universe, and ...
8
votes
1answer
249 views
9
votes
1answer
263 views
Can we reopen the question “When would the Undying Lands become over-populated?”
The question When would the Undying Lands become over-populated? was closed as opinion-based, but it has a definitive answer (never) because of specific things that Tolkien wrote. OP's assumption of "...
10
votes
1answer
441 views
Is this an unpopular type of question?
The question Is a rocket landing on a ship on an ocean literally “something from Science Fiction”? received several down votes in rapid succession. Comments suggest that while it may not be off-topic (...
2
votes
2answers
103 views
Not a dupe closed as dupe
I asked a question specifically looking for a canon source to Vogon Poet's claim that humans are immune to Pokemon attacks.
Are humans officially immune to Pokemon attacks?
I clearly linked to the ...
-18
votes
4answers
242 views
Can anything be done about prolific blind question bashing?
Many of my questions, no matter how good they are, are getting trounced by a few people who never leave a comment. It tends to be within a couple tags. It took less than 30 minutes for this group to ...
0
votes
1answer
63 views
Is this question too broad? "What are his wedding vows?"
I'm looking for what The Doctor said for his weddings, some think it's a broad question. For a week now the question seems to be in limbo.
7
votes
1answer
172 views
Is this truly a story-id question?
There's this question which is definitely a valid question. However, it's tagged with story-identification. Is this a valid tag and why? I honestly don't think it matches, but there doesn't seem to be ...
3
votes
3answers
263 views
Help me understand why my Star Trek question is on hold as 'unclear'?
Five people flagged my question from yesterday was "unclear" while not comments to help me understand why.
How did one specific torpedo hit the USS Enterprise in one specific episode of Star Trek: ...
12
votes
1answer
178 views
Why is my question "Chronological order of Star Wars Literature" closed for lists of works/recommendations?
I have a question that has bothered me since my question, "Chronological Order of Star Wars Literature", was closed for being off topic. In the note about why it was closed there is this titbit of ...
-4
votes
2answers
169 views
Why was the question "Why was Jake and the Never Land Pirates cancelled?" migrated to Movies?
Although cross-posting is frowned upon, it is considered acceptable to re-ask that question on to a new Stack Exchange site if you feel that the answers you received from the earlier time do not meet ...
1
vote
2answers
124 views
Why was this "future works policy" close flag declined as an improper use for flagging?
Note, I do not have close-vote privileges, so instead I have to use flags. The flag menu has an explicit "this question should be closed" submenu.
I flagged this question for closure with the custom ...
-2
votes
1answer
181 views
Answer-based reopen request
A (somewhat common?) point that is made by Primarily-Opinion-Based close-voters is that we can close questions that we think have never been addressed, and simply reopen them when someone does come up ...
-3
votes
2answers
84 views
Is the question "Does Iron Man's repulsor technology violate Newton's Third Law of Motion (in-universe)?" rightfully closed?
See this question:
Does Iron Man's repulsor technology violate Newton's Third Law of Motion (in-universe)?
It has been closed on the grounds that it's asking for real world "scientific ...
4
votes
0answers
47 views
Can this question be undeleted?
With the recent introduction of the Lifejacket and Lifeboat badges—and the disappearance of Tumbleweed—it occurred to me today that I ought to post a meta bounty on my own Tumbleweed question. ...
1
vote
1answer
74 views
How do we deal with terminology questions that turn out to be mere language questions? [duplicate]
Prompted by this question: Who is "He that flies" in Lord of the Rings?
The simple answer from comments
"He who flies" is a way of describing someone who is fleeing a battle. It doesn't ...
5
votes
2answers
265 views
Why is this question "primarily opinion-based?"
This question was put on hold as "primarily opinion based." I'm asking about the logic of time-loops in the movie, and received an answer as such. How is that opinion-based?
0
votes
1answer
199 views
How can I make my question about scheduling clear?
I recently asked a question about the scheduling at Hogwarts. The question was quite long, and the argumentation therein may have been confusing. That said, I thought the question itself was pretty ...
3
votes
3answers
378 views
Should the question about the number of rooms in The Burrow be closed as Primarily Opinion-Based?
Based on this Meta post it seems that the feeling is that there should be a dedicated Meta post discussing whether the specific question Why are there so few bedrooms in the Burrow? should be closed ...
-3
votes
1answer
211 views
How does this question fail the "related directly to a cited work of fiction" criterion?
The question How is Accio a safe spell? is closed with the following close reason:
Questions seeking scientific solutions or explanations are off-topic unless related directly to a cited work of ...
1
vote
1answer
329 views
Are all utopias and dystopias on-topic? [duplicate]
Utopias and dystopias are a genre loosely connected to Science Fiction and Fantasy. They often are set in the future, occasionally involve technology which has not yet been invented, and otherwise ...
15
votes
1answer
248 views
User changed their question into a completely different question. Is this allowed?
I was browsing the question feed just now when I came across this question about Iron Man and Captain America's fight in Civil War. I had it marked as a favourite, which confused me, as I'd never seen ...
6
votes
4answers
177 views
How do I ask this question about a SF author?
Frank Herbert's way of thinking is almost completely inside his books. Between the very few of his writes outside, there is an article resuming what his books are about and how he wrote these books.
...
-5
votes
1answer
145 views
Question falsely closed as duplicate
This question about Tolkien's mythology has been falsely closed as a duplicate of a question about one of Peter Jackson's movies.
As a Peter Jackson movie is not part of the mythology that Tolkien ...
2
votes
1answer
147 views
Can my question be lifted out of hold status? Can you specifically tell me how to improve it, because I have edited it
I have a question about my Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange post: What's so special about Harry Potter?
-1
votes
4answers
277 views
What is unclear about this question?
What does Grin refer to in Harry Potter?
Are there any other important references aside from this one:
Seamus Finnigan: "The Grin? What's the Grin?"
Bem: "Not the Grin, you idiot....
5
votes
1answer
240 views
Please clarify my question on why the audience may have been laughing at a speaker
The question is Laughing at Dr Alexander Murry's presentation. I initially got an upvote, but this was followed by 1 downvote and 4 close votes for "Unclear what you're asking". I have edited between ...
2
votes
1answer
156 views
Shall we delete this old, off-topic but highly viewed, question?
This question was recently bumped by edits: In what order should I read the Robert Langdon books? At first I was going to delete it because it's off-topic for our site, but then I saw the incredibly ...
13
votes
2answers
238 views
Do we still need to keep this thread locked?
I recently noticed What was the first work to posit the equivalence of magic rituals and computer algorithms? being pushed to the front page. Currently, every answer is locked (maybe due to spam edits ...
-10
votes
3answers
238 views
Why it's so hard to please the admins here on this site?
Consider the below question:-
Power of Infinity Stones in the Avengers Infinity War movie
Any lay person can also understand what I am asking here and that is:
Was the power of infinity stones ...
13
votes
1answer
292 views
What's the problem with this question?
I'm still quite new to StackExchange, and I like this place because here I've got a knowledgable community that can answer my questions. I try to keep my questions neutral in tone and try to avoid ...
1
vote
1answer
110 views
Is this question on topic - Can the T.H.A.N.O.S. theory be completed?
I feel like this may not be an answerable question and more specifically, that it may not be on topic, but I am curious and can not find anything online to satiate my interest...
Here is the question ...
11
votes
2answers
249 views
Should we prefer questions with accepted answers when closing identification requests as duplicate?
A couple of days ago, a story ID request was closed as a duplicate of another one.
Both have an answer which is correct, according to the querant.
But I saw that the one that was closed as a ...
9
votes
3answers
263 views
Is this question about The Great Mouse Detective on-topic?
I asked a question with the story-identification tag. The answer turned out to be that the movie I was thinking of was Disney's The Great Mouse Detective. For some reason, it became a popular network ...
2
votes
1answer
52 views
Can I ask for movies/books related with a particular sci-fi movie? [duplicate]
Since I'm done with the series and books of a sci-fi movie and can't decide whether what story should I read next, can I ask some recommendations of movie or book related to sci-fi? If this is allowed,...
1
vote
2answers
151 views
Why was this question closed as duplicate?
Are human-looking Jedi/Sith like Palpatine and the Skywalkers the same (human) species as non-Force users?
This question was recently marked as a duplicate. Two things bother me:
This question has ...
32
votes
2answers
823 views
Why can't I use the word "mudblood"?
In the question
How does reporting to muggle Prime Minister not violate International Statute of Wizarding Secrecy?
I used the word mudblood.
This was later changed to muggle-born (with edit ...
14
votes
3answers
246 views
Should we rewrite the 'lightsaber colour' question?
The question Can lightsabers be ochre? has a very comprehensive answer covering all possible lightsaber colours in both canon and Legends. For this reason, other lightsaber-colour questions such as ...
7
votes
0answers
124 views
Why was this question about why 'Voldemort became more snakelike' closed as a duplicate?
Regarding this question: Why does Voldemort become more snakelike?
The question links to the now marked duplicate here: How did Voldemort's face get disfigured?
The question and the post marked ...
-9
votes
1answer
139 views
Why is this question put on hold?
Some people have put this question on hold; it has lost its momentum and now will not be a Hot Network Question.
It has answers and is absolutely not too broad as there have not been very many ...
1
vote
1answer
79 views
Questions regarding similar things that separate universes share
I want to ask a question that involves a specific piece of technology that different sci-fi shows and movies share and how a particular aspect of the tech might work, and not necessarily as a direct ...
21
votes
1answer
410 views
Why was this question about Luke Skywalker ever closed?
Where has Luke Skywalker been?
This question is asking "Do we have any evidence of where he's been?"
Which is a cut and dried objective Yes/No no question, but it was closed as "primarily opinion ...