Questions tagged [comments]

For use when discussing the appropriateness and use of comments

Filter by
Sorted by
Tagged with
-4
votes
1answer
142 views

Why does this comment still remain?

I stumbled upon this comment attached to this question: It's Benjamin Effing Parker, dammit! I at first flagged it as "no longer needed" as it does not contribute to the question or discussion in ...
3
votes
1answer
104 views

Make it so that comments with “thanks” or similar words aren't automatically deleted

If I flag a comment such as "Thanks, that is the answer to my question" with "No longer needed", it will be deleted automatically without any mods looking at it. However, this could be really harmful ...
23
votes
5answers
435 views

Can something be done about unconstructive comments in star-trek-discovery questions?

For those unfamiliar, the new Star Trek series, Discovery, has proven controversial for many fans. Unfortunately many SFF users apparently feel the need to express their dissatisfaction every chance ...
4
votes
2answers
64 views

Can I add linebreaks to comment? How?

I often feel that it would make my comment much more clear if there is some line-break. For example, I sometimes want to add two different points in one comment and I would like to separate them as a ...
-8
votes
3answers
208 views

Why is it that people are persistent on critiquing a question in comments?

I don't understand the people critiquing a question in the comments such as, You have miss-understood what is happening here Your question premise is all wrong That is not what is really going on ...
-12
votes
1answer
382 views

Fighting answers in comments! [duplicate]

There is an astonishing amount of answers in comments here. Some of them gathered around 20 to 50 upvotes, and clearly provide a partial or full answer - and that isn't what the stack is for! What ...
17
votes
2answers
315 views

Has the policy on comments changed?

I've noticed that a couple of my comments on a question have been removed. Up until now I thought this site was pretty laid back with comments. Has that changed? FWIW the comments were on this ...
0
votes
1answer
292 views

Did this light-hearted one-line comment (based on experience!) breach some rule of the site?

I posted a comment on this question: a song of ice and fire - Are there any transgender characters in Westeros?. My comment was: "Anyone who thinks that Westeros is tough has never spent time in ...
4
votes
1answer
110 views

Why can't I add a comment?

I asked two Star Trek questions a while ago and I'm trying to comment back. For some reason I can't add a comment. Any help?
14
votes
0answers
121 views

Can we change the text of the generic NaA comment in the Low Quality Posts review?

The text, as it stands, is as follows: This does not provide an answer to the question. Once you have sufficient reputation you will be able to comment on any post; instead, provide answers that ...
21
votes
2answers
314 views

Why is calling questions “worthless” acceptable on this site?

Why is calling questions "worthless" acceptable on this site? The last instance was yesterday (when my R&A flag on such a comment was denied), but this wasn't the first nor even second time I saw ...
-36
votes
1answer
296 views

Who deletes comments? Is it the tooth fairy?

So Who deletes comments? I keep making insulting comments, but someone keeps deleting them. Is it the tooth fairy?
13
votes
2answers
346 views

What is the proper recourse for bubble-burster comments?

I'm sure most of you have seen the occasional cynical comment on questions with things like Because the author/screenwriters didn't think of it or It's just a story or some other such nonsense. This ...
11
votes
0answers
352 views

Why was this comment flag rejected?

I marked this comment as 'obsolete' since it related to the future release of a film, but one that is now released. I don't think this can be confirmed until the film is released on streaming or ...
0
votes
0answers
34 views

Unable to @tag in response to comments [duplicate]

I've noticed over the past couple months that, seemingly randomly, when I've attempted to respond to someone in the comments (with @Whatshisname) the username of the person I'm responding to will get ...
3
votes
1answer
61 views

Is it a bug that when @'ing another user that callout is deleted from a comment?

When attempting to @ another user, the @ callout disappeared after I'd submitted. Is this a bug? I also refreshed the page to be sure the comment I was trying to reply to hadn't been deleted. ...
16
votes
2answers
243 views

Do I need to get the interest of all people here before I ask a question?

I posted a question yesterday: Why does the Department of Mysteries keep prophecies? And somebody dropped a comment saying "I can't understand why people ask topics here that are not even ...
6
votes
1answer
65 views

How to post/link an image in a comment

It's easy if the image is online, just post the URL in the comment and hit enter - anyone who clicks it will see the image. Let's say I just photoshopped an image to help explain something to another ...
3
votes
1answer
85 views

Should a comment referenced from wiki be posted as an answer? [duplicate]

I posted a recent comment to this question: Is there any evidence that this character survived X-Men: Apocalypse? My comment basically referenced a quote from the wiki which didn't seem to have much ...
1
vote
1answer
187 views

Why this comment was appropriate?

I recently noticed this comment: "Fantastic. Thank you very much – Daniel Feb 11 at 5:53 " here: https://scifi.stackexchange.com/a/118033/44517 was flagged to delete it but the flag was declined: " ...
13
votes
2answers
332 views

Should I flag “Why all the Downvotes” comments as obsolete?

It is a frequent occurrence on this site that: Someone will ask a question. The question will get a downvote. The OP (or someone) else will post a comment saying "Why the downvote". Over time the ...
13
votes
3answers
182 views

Flag a comment for containing a spoiler when OP requested no spoilers?

In this question OP stated that they didn't want spoilers from preview chapters of The Winds of Winter. Somebody then went on to post a comment saying (paraphrased) "why would you exclude The Winds of ...
-2
votes
1answer
164 views

Proposal for enforcement of strict policies regarding Comments Deletion

Recently, lots of comments (which were not offensive or spam) got deleted from this question: Why doesn't Chewbacca learn to speak Galactic Basic? And, people are complaining in chat. I also didn'...
5
votes
2answers
83 views

Why were these comment flags declined, while the comments were deleted?

I flagged a number of comments on Wad Cheber's answer to the question what technologies were predicted by Back to the Future II. There was a discussion about the source of some statements that had ...
5
votes
0answers
45 views

Why can we only notify one additional user of a comment?

When we make a comment, why are we only permitted to notify one additional user? Sometimes there may be good reason to notify two or more users. What's the harm in that?
4
votes
3answers
371 views

Can I comment on my own question asking people to vote more?

I'm inquiring about this question: In the Netflix Daredevil series, is the "Black Sky" concept from any comic? It is the highest-view question so for this year by a margin of 26,000 (over ...
-10
votes
2answers
211 views

Why haven't any Diamond Moderator deleted big comments thread of top questions and answers?

A diamond moderator has pissed me off. Again. This question had very interesting comments which could have drawn new users to the site during this Avengers period: Why doesn't S.H.I.E.L.D. put ...
5
votes
3answers
158 views

Where did all the comments go on this question about the Hulk and SHIELD?

I recently posted a comment on this question: Why doesn't S.H.I.E.L.D. put Hulk on the index and lock him away? that included a link to some information about what the OP was asking. I did not ...
3
votes
0answers
61 views

Show comment upvotes on activity tab

Not sure if this would happen here or in the higher SE site, but I was wondering if would be possible to show comment votes when viewing comments we've left in the activity tab. For example, I often ...
3
votes
1answer
51 views

Why does my answer appear to be half-way to being converted into a comment?

I checked back on a question to which I had posted an answer and discovered that I allegedly also posted a comment with the same content (although truncated) at exactly the same time. What's going on ...
22
votes
5answers
500 views

What should we do about “funny” comments?

Sometimes people post jokey comments under questions and answers. Sometimes they're funny, sometimes not. What should we do about them? It seems (based on this conversation) that moderators are ...
8
votes
1answer
104 views

When deleting a comment I made, should I always flag replies as “obsolete”?

From time to time, I go through comments I made to see if they're still relevant and adding value to the site. If I delete a throw-away comment (I made), I flag any replies as "obsolete". But how ...
17
votes
3answers
281 views

Should we encourage or discourage posting generic “welcome comments” to all new users

Once in a while I see a large spike of generic comments which welcome pretty much every new user to the site. Should we encourage or discourage such practice? This doesn't apply to post-specific ...
2
votes
1answer
44 views

Do we have a default message template for new users that indicates how they can improve their post? [duplicate]

I find myself sometimes in the situation where I would like to comment on a new user's answer, how the site works and why their answer is downvoted. Do we have a default template for that or does ...
-5
votes
1answer
218 views

Can I please get the deleted comments made on this question? [closed]

Comments made on this question have been deleted: Why did Lucas choose the word "Force"? I want to get a deleted comment which was a scolding full of alien terms. Is this possible to get ...
10
votes
1answer
95 views

Which flag reason should I use when flagging comments?

When I'm flagging a comment, which flag reason should I use?
8
votes
2answers
94 views

Should all comments that have 1+ and little else in them be flagged

I am saying this because I have seen a lot of comments that say things that like: 1+ for the awesome answer or question 1+ for the detail 1+ I always wondered that I have read this question but ...
1
vote
1answer
64 views

Are comments on-topic if they are referring to downvotes and other questions?

I flagged the comment trail here as off-topic, but my flag was declined. I'm confused as to how downvotes and Captain Kirk are on-topic to a question about two Babylon 5 characters. Why was my flag ...
5
votes
1answer
61 views

commenting on an edit

I can address a comment to the author of a post, or to a user who has commented on the post, but unless I'm missing something there is no way to address a comment to a user who has edited without ...
1
vote
0answers
44 views

Invalid linkification in comments

I just tried to link to this page in a comment: http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Treachery,_Faith_and_the_Great_River_%28episode%29 Unfortunately, the shorthand used in comments sometimes breaks on ...
-1
votes
1answer
165 views

Why can't I post a comment anymore?

Is anyone else getting this or is it just me? I seem to be able to ask questions, or at least the option is there and it brings up the dialog box. I have not gone all the way to posting a question ...
5
votes
1answer
65 views

Can the moderators convert a comment into an answer?

I know that moderators can take an answer that should be a comment, and turn it into a comment (attributed to same poster). Can moderators do the reverse (turn comment into an answer posted by same ...
12
votes
1answer
125 views

When, if ever, should we flag comments as “obsolete”?

I recently happened to take another look at an old answer of mine, and noticed that there was a fair amount of chatty comments between myself and the OP of the question I was answering. The comments ...
3
votes
2answers
97 views

Why was my comment correcting terminology deleted?

I recently posted a comment to a question about the Wizard of Oz using Black and White then transitioning to color. The answer used the word "greyscale" rather than "black and white". I made a ...
3
votes
1answer
89 views

How does user tagging in comments really work?

When you comment directly to people, the usual routine is to '@user yes, but, but'. With users of certain lower[new, or uninvolved] reps, or lower age, it simply doesn't work. Try to comment on this ...
12
votes
2answers
255 views

How to comment on “There is no in-universe answer”/“plot hole” answers lacking any evidence?

Sometimes a question is asked to which the answer is posted stating "There is no in-universe answer" (aka "it's a plot hole"). Such answers in and of themselves are OK in general, but as discussed in ...
8
votes
2answers
104 views

How to comment on answers lacking citations

What is some good boilerplate for a comment on a post that lacks citations or references? When you see a post that appears to be pure conjecture, not backed up by or referencing the source material, ...
18
votes
3answers
292 views

Answering Questions with a Comment

When answering a question, I've noticed that sometimes a sleuth will answer in the comment section with a complete answer, as opposed to with a formal answer. Are there any reasons to do this, and ...
6
votes
1answer
45 views

Tweak language of 'move this discussion to chat' link

When there are a large number of comments on a post, you are prompted with this if you go to add another comment: Please avoid extended discussions in comments. Would you like to automatically move ...
11
votes
3answers
332 views

How can I find the most upvoted comment(s) on a site?

I saw one comment today that (deservedly so) was upvoted to +14 in a couple of hours. Is there a way to find all the "good" - meaning highest-upvoted - comments on the entire site? I'd strongly ...