4

Which was the first novel set in universes where P=NP?

I've been wanting this to be reopened since before I was a mod.

Since it's been asked, the community reaction to 'first of'type questions had softened remarkably.

I think the answers within are good quality examples of how to answer such questions. And I think the question in its own seems genuine.

What does the community think?

| |
  • 3
    Maybe it would help to explain why you think it worth reopening? – Jon Ericson Feb 15 '16 at 19:30
  • @JonEricson There seems to be (according to current SFF consensus) no reason for it to be closed. I'm not sure why it was closed in the first place - perhaps at that time origins questions were considered as bad as list questions? - but like Alex said, it wouldn't be closed if it was asked today. – Rand al'Thor Feb 15 '16 at 20:36
9

Yes, it should be reopened.

We have quite a few “first of” questions on the site, which have been generally well-received. Picking a few examples at random:

Your example fits into the mould of these posts.

I think these are good and interesting questions:

  • They tell us something about the history of the genre
  • They are often an introduction to important works (cf. story ID questions)
  • The best answer is usually easy to distinguish – it’s hard to argue about the meaning of “first”. (Which doesn’t preclude the possibility of an earlier work which nobody has mentioned yet, but it does give an easy way to sort the existing answers.)

Finally, I’d note that the “not constructive” close reason has been gone for a while. If this question were to be re-asked today, I don’t think it would be closed.

| |
  • 2
    Agreed. It also let me to a wonderful Charles Stross story. – SQB Feb 15 '16 at 19:38

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .