Are answers that stem from our own personal interpretation of the work useful and kosher here?

I recently answered Was Harry Potter killed and then brought back to life? and my answer was completely based on how I interpreted the scene referenced in the book/movie without me needing to go to a wiki or outside source other than the book itself.

Is first hand research allowed?

  • Isn't a comment enough for a personal opinion? – Bebs V Dec 12 '16 at 14:11

A interpretation could be good, if it's backed with several fact and explanation that lead to this interpretation. However, it could be contradicted/overpowered by other things like citation and/or interview of the author.

The problem with your answer was that it was contradicted with some element from the book.

An other example of this is in Who *really* wrote the Rama sequels?. My answer is a citation and the other is an assumption. Both are valid answer, but the community judged the citation more relevant.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .