-1

In this question I want to reply to the second part of the answer which is spoilered (as I spoilered my question). But the spoiler markdown doesn't work in comments (>!).

Would it be possible to allow spoilers in comments?

  • 2
    Can you not just obliquely refer to the material in the comment? – Tony Meyer Jun 5 '11 at 23:15
5

Comments are intentionally second-class citizens and lightweight in terms of implementation requirements and user experience impact. I don't think adding another feature to them will be well-received. If “spoiler” comments existed at all, the whole comment would probably be a spoiler, and even then I don't think the feature has much chance of being accepted.

I don't like it much myself. Comments are already displayed in a low-key way; I don't think you'll be reading them by accident. I'd be quite comfortable with a “comments are always spoily” policy, especially on answers.

2

If you really need to include a spoiler in a comment, and you are not commenting on a post that implicitly spoils the respective plot-element, just prefix it with a written spoiler warning indicating what exactly will be spoiled by the comment.

Example:

[WARNING: Integral plot details of "Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back" will be spoiled by reading this.] The argument in your answer is wrong, because when Luke meets Vader in Cloud City it is disclosed that Vader is actually Luke's father. So, he couldn't possibly have been a time travelling robot from the future.

1

You could rot-13 the spoiler:

Lbqn vf Yhxr'f sngure!

If you're feeling friendly, you could even link to a decoder/encoder.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .