2

This question seems very simple and easy to answer. In fact it tempts users to post link only answers.

Its not a true list question in my mind but it still doesn't sit right with me. I want to close, and I don't.

Does the community have any thoughtsthou on this?

2
  • 1
    When I can, I try to point them someplace that already does this, and summarize it in the answer. For example, this question about Stargate "arc" episodes – Izkata Dec 13 '13 at 4:45
  • Frankly, I'm strongly suspicious of any claim of "this is trivially answerable" not backed up by... well, a trivially obtained answer ... *hint* *hint* – DVK-on-Ahch-To Dec 14 '13 at 23:27
5

I think the question shows little to no research effort, but it's essentially a question, where the 'story' is a story arc. I'm fine with leaving it, but I'm downvoting the answers that are just links.

I'm also downvoting because neither of those answers actually answer the question. If I ask you which episodes of a show contain an element, and you just link me to a list of every episode, you're not answering my question. That's essentially what these answers are doing, in addition to just being links.

1
  • Well, it finally got an actual answer to the question. I'm giving them a cookie as thanks. – user1027 Dec 16 '13 at 18:48
1

I share Keen's opinion of the current answers, however, in concept it's a perfectly valid question ("which of the episodes of a show constitute a specific story arc") not nearly worthy of VTCing and perfectly on-topic and in-scope.

If you feel that the answer is trivial to obtain (not being an SME, I don't see how it would be), you can and should:

(1) Post the correct answer - as Izkata stated, a link to existing resource would be a good format[1].

(2) Down-vote the question for not doing obvious research, ...

(2b) ... ideally with a comment explaining to noobs like me JUST what you did to research it as learning aid.


[1] - IMHO, we have enough rep whores on SFF.SE that if it was, indeed, trivially answerable, we would more likely than not have already seen a good correct answer. The fact that one is missing leads me to be slightly skeptical of your assessment concerning the simplicity of answering it

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .