9

I noticed on Pureferret's question What happened to the Heroes from Diablo 1?, C. Ross mentions that the exact same question was asked on Gaming.SE. I don't think that means the question should be closed as an exact duplicate, but I wanted to ask on meta.

If a question has an exact duplicate on a different SE site, should it be closed as a duplicate?

  • Cross-posting of questions is actively discouraged. I'll check and see if I can find some references. – Beofett May 3 '12 at 12:22
6

Most of the discussion I have found is on cross-posting, rather than incidental duplication on different sites.

Overlap such as video game story/lore elements being on topic for both gaming.se and scifi.se is rather unusual, and generally the exception to the rule.

However, it seems there are some accepted guidelines that cover this situation. There are also a few grey areas, which I will outline.

Deliberately cross-posting is indeed something that is strongly discouraged. Part of the justification for this is that "99.99% of questions people have claimed as being cross site has been proven to be valid on a single site if written properly and thought through". I think that this specific scenario (scifi/fantasy video game lore) is that "0.01%". Both communities have explicitly stated that these types of questions are on topic.

Jeff's answer states pretty clearly that cross-posting is bad?

However, this meta discussion, created at around the same time as the previous one, has a slightly different take on cross-posting, claiming that it is okay so long as it is not "abusive".

Robert Harvey clarifies when cross-posting is considered "abusive". More importantly, he references a comment by Robert Cartaino:

Robert Cartaino is right; there's no concept of closing as a duplicate on another site. Down that road lies madness.

So... deliberately posting on both sites is probably not the best idea, unless you can tailor one question to focus on the gaming community's perspective, and another on the scifi/fantasy community's. However... two different users posting very similar questions on each site seems perfectly fine.

  • 2
    I'd emphacise the "you can tailor one question to focus on the gaming community's perspective, and another on the scifi/fantasy community's". They don't HAVE to be duplicates in the first place – DVK-on-Ahch-To May 3 '12 at 16:02

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .