The question in question: What to read in History of Middle-earth?
It's had a little bit of history to it, originally closed as a dupe to: In what order should Tolkien's writings on Middle-earth be read? where I was one of the close voters. However, after further discussion in the comments I think this one is sufficiently different to that and it was reopened.
It has later been closed as "Opinion based". However, suggested-order questions, which this is, generally do not fall under "Opinion based" and are the type of good subjective questions we allow.
Having already voted to reopen it the first time around I now can't do so again and probably shouldn't to stop a close/reopen war.
Should this question have been closed?