2

I am not a The Witcher expert, but as I understood there are some differences between the books and the show, also there is a very well-known game, another TV show and so on.

Some of the questions could/should be about only one of them.

I know we have only one tag even for bigger universes, like or but there are a lot of complementary tags for them (characters, episodes, books, etc.)

The question is: Should we have some tags for the different works? For example, something like or or maybe even both?

| |
  • I don't see the need for it, as far as I'm aware the Netflix adaptation is very faithful to The Last Wish which it is based off of. – TheLethalCarrot Jan 9 at 11:17
  • 1
    If you want to restrict it to a specific medium you can always say so in the question and use the media tags to do so, i.e. [the-witcher] [tv]. That's how we do it for other works, [harry-potter] being a good example of that I believe. – TheLethalCarrot Jan 9 at 11:20
  • Title revision: Toss a coin...erhm... tag to your Witcher... – Skooba Jan 17 at 19:49
4

One tag for the whole franchise: .

It's fine to define subtags as we've done in other franchises, but there should be one overarching tag so that someone who's interested in the whole franchise, everything Witcher related, can get all of that in a single list or by following a single tag. Also, many questions are going to be about the whole franchise without restricting to books, game, TV show, etc. If someone wants to know something about the Witcher lore, very often they won't care which part of the lore the answer comes from.

Media tags ...

Our usual approach when a single story or franchise has been adapted for different media is to use media tags, for example , , . In this case, things are complicated by the fact that, as you mention, there are two different TV series which are both in the same franchise but independent of each other. For the 2002 one we could create a tag (noting in the tag description that it's a subtag of and should always be used together with that), but for the 2019 one it's a bit harder because the name of the TV series is the same as the name of the franchise. But maybe the tags would be enough in this case (we seem to have had no questions about The Hexer anyway), less confusing than creating a new or tag.

| |
  • Yeah at the moment we don't really need any new tags creating, just use with a media tag if you want to restrict it. – TheLethalCarrot Jan 9 at 11:25

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .