New user Eyeball asked a question with the not entirely coherent title "I am looking for a book of short stories by Isaac Asimov written by other authors" which prompted these comments (among others):
..."A book of short stories by Isaac Asimov written by other authors" is rather confusing. Can you clarify what you mean?
"...edited by Asimov,", I assume OP means.
I provided an answer to a part of the question, but thereafter another new user edited the title to read "I am looking for a book of other author's short stories edited by Isaac Asimov" without Eyeball having responded to the comments to provide any indication of what they may have meant by their original title.
Without Eyeball's input I would not have made this edit to the title, and was surprised to see it so-edited.
I am also uncertain about rolling the edit back (after all, other users need not exercise my editorial judgement :). But I asked Valorum in comments about the edit, who replied:
I'd be happier if they confirmed it since the edit changes the meaning of the post (although admittedly it also changes it from incoherent to coherent)
In the absence of input from Eyeball, should Ms.Tamil's edit be rolled back (since it substantively changes the meaning of the question, by resolving its original incoherence in a particular way)?
I am interested in an answer, even if Eyeball (the OP) returns to clarify for or against the edit.