10

The tag (99 questions) has the following tag wiki excerpt (and no tag wiki):

Refers to musical themes, cues, or scores present in works of science fiction. Usually used in relation to film or tv series.

In practice, the tag seems to have been used for at least three different types of questions.

  1. Questions about music which appears in a work of sci-fi or fantasy, e.g. Which version of the Imperial March plays just after Vader gets his new suit? and What are the lyrics and translation for the Nazgûl theme music?
  2. Questions about music which refers to a work of sci-fi or fantasy, e.g. What is the first mention of Star Wars in a hit song? and Which Star Trek: TNG episodes are sampled in the song "Data & Picard" from artist Pogo?
  3. Story-ID questions about stories with a musical theme, e.g. Short stories with musical themes and What is short story of man stranded on planet with a musical alien

We also have a second tag , with 5 questions all of which fall into the first of the three categories listed above.

How should these tags actually be used?

  • Are we OK with being used for three different types of question? If not, should we split it into two or three different tags and/or retag some questions? Should we rewrite the tag wiki?
  • Does deserve to be a separate tag, or should it be merged into ?
  • 1
    What about the other tags such as rock-music, musical (probably relevant to story-id), and music-video? – Skooba Nov 3 '17 at 12:39
  • @Skooba Oh good lord, how deep does this pit go? – Rand al'Thor Nov 3 '17 at 14:31
6

Merge them.

Music is broad term, but reasonably well understood in the context of our site. Experts in the production and usage of music within the works of science fiction and fantasy will likely have a range of applicable knowledge.

The last question was asked roughly two years at the time of this posting. While an inactive tag shouldn't just go away, it gives us a good indication that the broader is likely to garner better results for searching, asking, and answering questions.

As for the different usages we have seen... all that takes is a well written tag-wiki!

  • I like the idea of musical being better, although I strongly approve of this non-deletion belief – Edlothiad Nov 3 '17 at 15:38
  • OK, if this meta post remains upvoted I'll merge the two tags. What about the different usages of music? – Rand al'Thor Nov 4 '17 at 9:40
  • 1
    all that takes is a well written tag-wiki - but first we have to define a definition for which use is appropriate before writing the wiki... – user58 Nov 12 '17 at 7:36

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .