0

How short can a story identification question be and still be reasonably answerable? For example:

  1. Firemen set fires, burn books

  2. Sex-changing time-traveller is his own mother and father

  3. Columbus has radio, sails off the edge

  4. Immortal shrunken ancestors stored on underground shelves

  5. Giant space worms devastate Earth, carry survivors to the stars as parasites

  • 1
    I think you'd be one of the best to answer this question no? I say challenge time: let's find the shortest question you can answer! – Möoz Oct 10 '17 at 2:19
4

The problem with a very short questions is that although they might look answerable, unfortunately science fiction and fantasy writers have a tendency to recycle tropes both from their own earlier works and from other writers. Your first example, for example (Firemen set fires, burn books) could be the iconic Fahrenheit 451 or it could just as easily be an earlier work, The Fireman (in this case by the same author).

Per my answer to How to ask a good story-ID question?, a good story-ID question should contain sufficient information for it to be uniquely identifiable. A very short question is unlikely to have that although if they're as memorable as the ones you've given as examples, you could probably get away with it.


That all being said, I'd probably downvote such a question for being intentionally unhelpful and "clever". This site isn't a puzzle factory. We aren't here to solve Story-ID questions with as few clues as possible.

  • I was of course aware that "The Fireman" and Fahrenheit 451 were both possible answers for #1, and I sure wouldn't consider the question too broad on that account; a good answer will mention both versions, unless the question was tagged short-story or novel. And I still wouldn't consider it too broad if there is another very obscure story about book-burning firemen. – user14111 Oct 10 '17 at 7:05
  • And it goes without saying that people with real questions should not try to make their questions as terse as possible, like I did in my examples. On the other hand, somethmes they really don't remember very much. And some story ID questions really are too broad. But I have dark suspicions that some of the people voting to close them as too broad would be hard-pressed to name even one story that matches the description. – user14111 Oct 10 '17 at 7:11
  • 2
    @user14111 - I don't need to come up with a half-dozen examples before I vote something as "too broad". Simply identifying that it's a common enough trope is sufficient. – Valorum Oct 10 '17 at 7:25
  • Puzzling.SE isn't a 'puzzle factory'... – Mithrandir Oct 10 '17 at 7:34
  • 1
    @Mithrandir - Yes it is. And the only serious attempt to stop it being one resulted in site-bans and dozens of users leaving in disgust. – Valorum Oct 10 '17 at 7:37
  • You don't need to come up with anything to vote for anything. Casting a justified VTC is another story. Personally, I find it hard to accept that something is a common "trope" when I can't think of a single story that matches the description, but I've seen those closed as too broad. – user14111 Oct 10 '17 at 7:47
4

It's not about length, it's about answerability.

I'm not sure if this has ever been enshrined in meta law, but in practice it's what I've always observed.

If an ID question is uniquely answerable, then it can be left open.
If there are multiple answers which fit the description, then it's too broad.

(Interestingly enough, this is also the same criterion used for riddles on Puzzling SE, which actually have a lot in common with ID questions here: something is described via various details and answerers need to find its name. The difference is, as Valorum has already mentioned, that ID questions here are just meant to be answerable, not necessarily challenging.)

In the past we've allowed some very short ID questions to remain open precisely because they're uniquely answerable. Length shouldn't really be a consideration when deciding whether or not to VTC.

(I'm aware that other SE sites have found this policy impractical and vote to close questions based on 'quality' considerations as well as just answerability. But SFF hasn't had massive problems with ID question quality, and this is AFAIK the criterion most people use here for closability of ID questions.)

2

It really just depends on whether people can figure out the answers. These are not quiz questions, after all; the goal is to get people answers to their queries, not to prove anything about how clever or knowledgeable the answerers are. If people somebody can figure out the answer just from a single-sentence blurb, then that's all that is really needed. Obviously, well-known works are going to be easier to identify. Of the five on your list, I was able to get the first two without even a second thought.

Moreover, while there are guidelines for what makes a good story identification question, we ultimately cannot control how much information a questioner has about the work the are looking for. Some works are only very vaguely remembered, and some questions come to us second hand. It is not always possible to add more detail about when a book was read, or what the style of animation of a film was. The "best" questions are those that provide the most information, because they are the easiest to answer; and because they are will be the most useful to other people looking for the same work in the future. However, that does not mean that questions with less information are unanswerable; they are just harder.

Sometimes, a very minimal question will get a prompt answer, and the original asker will agree that the right work has been found. In cases like this, it might be advantageous to edit more information into the question and/or answer after it has been confirmed. However, by the most elementary indicator, the question has been successful: An answer was found. Thus, ipso facto, the question was not too broad or vague to be answerable.

  • 1
    Of course the askers should tell us everything they remember, and of course sometimes that's not going to be very much. It seems to me that some people here are in a hurry to close story-identification questions as "too broad" without stopping to think, are there really a whole bunch of stories that fit the description? "What's that story where Earth is invaded by space aliens", OK, too broad. "What's that story where the advance scout for the alien invaders is a handsome crooner with X-ray eyes who falls for an Earth girl with a well-shaped clavicle", maybe not. – user14111 Oct 9 '17 at 23:40

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .